TURN Newsroom
Power Play: No Limits Mean PG&E May Raise Rates Again for Northern and Central Californians
Source: Capital and Main | By Mark Kreidler
“Talk about audacity – not only do they want to charge for what they didn’t get authorization to spend ahead of time, but they also want to collect most of the money before the commission even authorizes the retroactive amount,” said Mark Toney, head of the utility reform network TURN, which provided Capital & Main with several documents related to PG&E’s multiple requests for rate increases. “It’s certainly significant.” Toney estimated that customers will see at least $12 per month and as much as $20 per month added to their bills if the CPUC approves this latest rate hike and early collection plan. Added to the new $33 monthly increase, average annual bills could jump between $540 and $640 this year alone. Toney said that PG&E’s ultimate goal is to recover all of that overspend on the backs of its ratepayers, one hike at a time — one reason TURN is pushing for a cap on the percent of increase a utility can ask in any given year. “There simply can’t be no limits to what they can ask for,” the advocate said, but that is exactly what is in play here in 2024.
Only a few weeks after receiving approval from the California Public Utilities Commission for that roughly $400 annual rate hike late last year, PG&E went right back to the well. In a Dec. 1 filing, the utility asked the CPUC for permission to pass along another $2 billion in cost overruns as part of its ongoing process of updating wildfire mitigation and repairing storm damage.
Would You Pay $1/month For Your Neighbor’s Heat Pump?
Source: Politico | By Wes Venteicher
Consumer advocacy groups including the CPUC’s Public Advocates Office and The Utility Reform Network also oppose the proposal. TURN says it would sour moderate-income customers on the energy transition by making them pay for others’ heat pumps, and would hurt low-income customers by switching them to more-expensive electricity instead of cheaper natural gas. “We’ve got to look at the big picture here and look at where we’re going,” said Mark Toney, TURN’s executive director. “Yes, we need to electrify and we’re in support of that, but there have got to be other ways to do it.”
A proposal by Southern California Edison up for approval at this Thursday’s Public Utilities Commission meeting would charge ratepayers for 250,000 heat pumps for low-income residents. But regulators are balking at the cost. Heat pumps, as you’ll recall, are a priority of both President Joe Biden, whose Inflation Reduction Act provides tax credits of up to $2,000 for them, and Gov. Gavin Newsom, whose California Energy Commission last year set a goal of 6 million pumps by 2030. Southern California Edison laid out stark numbers in its pitch to the California Public Utilities Commission: The state is on track to install only 4.7 million pumps by 2030, according to the utility’s analysis. Charging customers up to $734 million — or less than $1 per month on average, according to the utility — would help make up the difference in SCE’s territory, it says.
Latest Proposed PG&E Rate Hike Could Push Average Monthly Bill Over $300
Source: CBS News | By John Ramos
"These rate increases are completely out of control," Toney said. "We have a system that is broken, where there are no limits to how much PG&E can ask for or how many times a year they can ask for it." TURN is advocating that utility rates be capped at the rate of inflation of Social Security. In a statement, PG&E said, "...we're aggressively focused on finding new ways to work so that we can keep future bill increases at or below a broader, long-term inflation rate of 2% to 4%." But Toney said he thinks utility bills should only deal with delivery of power, and that other costs like wildfire mitigation should be paid through the state budget.
Homeowners across the Bay Area have seen their power bills climbing, but the latest request for an increase will reach a historic milestone -- more than $300 for the average monthly PG&E bill. "Shocking, maddening and frustrating!" That's how Janet Kimball described the utility bill for her Pleasant Hill home.
PG&E Average Monthly Bills are Set to Top $300 for the First Time
Source: Silicon Valley | By George Avalos
The state PUC should act to rein in soaring PG&E bills, in the view of Mark Toney, executive director of the consumer group, The Utility Reform Network (TURN). “The current system that sets no limits on rate increases needs to be replaced by a cap on annual bills, set at the cost-of-living adjustment provided by Social Security,” according to a web post by TURN.
PG&E’s request to raise rates this spring — in part due to wildfire prevention work — are poised to propel utility bills past a grim milestone: Charges are slated to average more than $300 a month for the first time. This month, bills for the typical residential customer climbed to $294.50. That’s already the highest average monthly bill ever for PG&E customers.
PG&E and State Farm Increase their Rates in the Bay Area
Source: Telemundo Bay Area | By Bob Redell, NBC Bay Area, & Libertad Pedraza
Ratepayer advocacy group TURN said PG&E could ask customers to refund them. The rate increase already approved will increase the average PG&E bill by $34. PG&E is also separately requesting another increase in March. If that passes, the average bill could rise again by $24. PG&E could also request another increase of about $43 a month. That brings the total to $100 more for the average monthly bill. "The California Public Utilities Commission is in charge of reviewing every rate increase request and, unfortunately, has repeatedly sided with Wall Street investors instead of regular customers," said the CEO of TURN, Mark Toney. "That's why bills have skyrocketed so much in recent years."
PG&E has raised its rates and now the state's largest home insurer is about to do the same. State Farm, which insures about one in 10 to 11 homes in the Bay Area and the rest of California, has received approval from the state Department of Insurance to increase rates by an average of 20% per homeowner.
PG&E Becomes California's Most Expensive Power Provider
Source: NBC Bay Area | By Jaxon Van Derbeken
“We have an extremely bad problem on our hands,’’ said Mark Toney, head of The Utility Reform Network (TURN), a ratepayer advocacy group. He says the utility is playing catchup on rates, having spent far more than authorized for tree cutting and other efforts to reduce wildfires between 2020 and 2022. According to an accounting PG&E submitted to state regulators for that three year period, the utility spent $9.3 billion more than the $4.7 billion allotted in rates by the California Public Utilities Commission for vegetation management.
PG&E has filed paperwork with regulators to raise rates another $24 a month, for the average customer, in March, to pay for storm repairs and more wildfire mitigation costs. On top of that, according to a chart PG&E recently showed shareholders, the utility indicates it intends to seek even more, to recoup billions it already spent.
PG&E Proposes Additional Price Hike
Source: KRON 4 | By Dan Kerman
“There’s no limit to this,” said Mark Toney with the Utility Reform Network. “This is part of the problem. Every single increase you hear about is a tip of the iceberg and every increase that on top of the previous one.” Toney opposes this additional hike and says annual increases must be capped at the same level as the cost-of-living adjustment provided by social security.
Californians are turning up the heat as cooler rainy weather arrives, which causes utility bills to rise. But come this month customers will also see increases due to a rate hike, as combined gas and electric bills go up an average of 13 percent, or $34.50 a month.
PG&E Customers in Oakland Grapple with Steep Utility Bill Increase
Source: BNN Breaking | By Olalekan Adigun
The Utility Reform Network (TURN), a notable consumer advocacy group, has been vocal in its criticism of the rate hikes. It argues for the need for regulatory caps on rate increases and advocates for a system where they are tied to cost of living adjustments, akin to those in place for Social Security. The group asserts that this approach could mitigate the financial strain on consumers, particularly those in lower income brackets.
As the dawn of 2024 broke, residents of Oakland woke up to an unwelcome New Year’s surprise: a hefty surge in their monthly electric and gas bills. In the face of public outcry, PG&E defends the rate increases, claiming they are necessary to fund essential improvements to their energy systems. The aim is to reduce wildfire risks and enhance safety and reliability for all users. These ambitious improvement plans include burying powerlines in fire-prone areas and replacing aging gas pipelines, among other measures.
PG&E Electric and Gas Monthly Bills Hop Over $290 Mark to Start 2024
Source: The Mercury News | By George Avalos
Regulators, and potentially lawmakers, must act to rein in soaring PG&E bills and take steps to ensure they are in line with the overall inflation rate, in the view of Mark Toney, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, or TURN, a consumer group. “The current system that sets no limits on rate increases, needs to be replaced by a cap on annual bills, set at the cost of living adjustment provided by Social Security,” TURN, a consumer group, states on its website. Adjustments for the cost of living are typically tied to a benchmark for inflation.
PG&E monthly bills are expected to average roughly $294.50 a month for the typical residential customer who receives combined electricity and gas services from the utility behemoth, according to estimates provided by the company to this news organization. That combined bill is 22.3% higher than the average monthly charges that went into effect about a year ago, at the start of January 2023, when combined bills were $240.73 for the typical residential customer.
PG&E Is Raising Monthly Rates Even Higher in 2024
Source: The San Francisco Standard | By Kevin Truong
Mark Toney, the executive director of The Utility Reform Network, a consumer advocacy group, said the lack of limits on rate increases is leading to a squeeze on a critical service for customers. "There's no limits on much PG&E can ask for and how many times a year they can ask. There's also no limits on how much [regulators] can authorize," Toney said. "That's why they can ask for another rate increase just weeks after they already received one." Toney's group is pushing for a limit cap on increases that are set at the cost-of-living allowances provided by social security.
Starting Jan. 1, the typical PG&E electricity and gas customer will see their monthly rates rise about $34.50—13%—compared to current bills. That works out to $414 more in utility payments for the year, which would mark a historic increase.
Advocates Want More Black Californians Involved in State’s Transition to EVs
Source: SD Voice | By Maxim Elramsisy
When Los Angeles hosted its annual car show a little over a month ago at the LA Convention Center, it not only showcased the latest in automotive technology, but the event also transformed into a policy forum on clean energy, previewing what lies ahead for California’s electric vehicle (EV) future. Battery-powered cars took center stage. They accounted for the majority of the over 1000 vehicles on display, ranging from cars and trucks to motorcycles, recreational vehicles, and semi-trucks. For Black and other minority advocates in attendance, several concerns emerged. Among them were the impact of the transition to zero emissions vehicles (ZEVs) on Black Californians and how the state will equip low-income neighborhoods with the infrastructure needed when California bans the sale of all gas-powered vehicles in 2035.
Rising Utility Costs Compound California's Housing Crisis
Source: KQED | By Vanessa Rancaño
Many people who lose access to utilities end up moving in with others, restarting their utilities under someone else’s name, or leaving the state, said Mark Toney, executive director of the consumer advocacy group The Utility Reform Network. “But some of those people absolutely do end up homeless,” he said.
A quarter of California households reported being unable to pay their utility bills in October, according to a Census survey, resulting in what Columbia University public health professor Diana Hernández and others call energy insecurity, or the “heat or eat dilemma.” “It’s almost like a game of Russian roulette,” she said, describing the monthly juggle low-income families face. “Today’s unpaid energy bill is tomorrow’s eviction notice. And that cycle is a very real one.”
Diablo Canyon, the Last Remaining Nuclear Power Plant in California, Gets a Lifeline
Source: The San Diego Union-Tribune | By Rob Nikolewski
The Utilities Reform Network (TURN), a consumer group based in San Francisco, is concerned that last-minute revisions approved by the CPUC on Thursday could leave ratepayers on the hook. “We’re very disturbed that the proposed decision may allow PG&E to collect a $1.4 billion slush fund from ratepayers that it would use specifically to protect its shareholders from any liability for core performance,” TURN staff attorney Matthew Freedman said.
The California Public Utilities Commission approved a plan Thursday to keep the Diablo Canyon Power Plant near San Luis Obispo open for at least six more years. The decision “is an important measure towards supporting the reliability of the California electricity grid as we move forward in our energy transition,” said Karen Douglas, the commissioner assigned to the case. “California’s path forward in the energy transition hasn’t always been easy and won’t always be easy.”
Utility Company Cites Climate Change in Push for Additional Rate Hikes
Source: Blaze Media | By Candace Hathaway
The Utility Reform Network, a nonprofit group opposed to the "outrageous" rate hikes, accused PG&E of gouging its customers. "It's gonna be between $12 and $20 additional each month. That's on top of the $33 that's coming January 1," said Mark Toney, the network's executive director. "They want them to start collecting in March, even before the CPUC has held a proceeding and decided whether PG&E should get paid back by rate payers; $2 billion for overspending," Toney continued. "Oh, PG&E has several requests for at least another $3 billion." Toney explained that the electric company is attempting to get customers to cover costs "for something that has not even happened." He noted that the Utility Reform Network is partnering with legislators to set price increase limits to protect customers.
Pacific Gas and Electric Company customers will see their bills increase by $33 per month starting at the beginning of the year. However, PG&E claims it is not enough to protect against climate concerns. The utility company is now seeking approval for another rate hike that will increase monthly bills by $12-$20 per month on top of the already-approved New Year's Day increases that have yet to appear on customers' bills.
Here's What Your Pacific Gas and Electric Bill Will Look Like Next Year
Source: SF Gate | By Madilynne Medina
This interim rate would add another $12 - $20 to customers’ bills per month for a year starting in May, on top of the recently approved 12.8% boost, Mark Toney, executive director of TURN – The Utility Reform Network, said in a Tuesday statement. That would mean a total hike per month of $40 to $60 over what customers paid in 2023, Toney said.
Be prepared for your PG&E bill to be higher next year. Starting with their bill sent in February, customers will pay on average about $30 to $35 per month more than what they paid in 2023. The increase, which takes effect Jan. 1, comes as the result of unanimous approval last month by the California Public Utilities Commission of a 12.8% rate hike. And if PG&E gets its way, an additional increase could land later in the year
PG&E: Mark Toney, Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Source: KMJ Now | By Broeske and Musson
Less than a month after rate hikes were approved, PG&E wants another $2 billion from customers. INTERVIEW: Mark Toney/Executive Director, Utility Reform Network (TURN) discusses what he's trying to do to stop the extra increase.
PG&E Pushes for Additional Price Hikes
Source: KRON 4 | By Terisa Estacio
“This is outrageous to have this again on top of that increase puts $30 on our bills,” Mark Toney, executive director of TURN, watchdog agency The Utility Reform Network. Toney is not holding back on his perspective of PG&E saying it needs more money. “This would put $12 on top of the $30,” Toney said.
Last month, the California public utilities commission approved an increase in monthly bills that would add about thirty dollars for gas and electricity users. Now the utility company is back to the table asking for more money that would impact customers. PG&E filed an application to the California Public Utilities Commission on Dec. 1. It lays out why the utility company says it needs $2 billion from rate payers. They claim it is for safety reasons.
PG&E Requests Another Rate Increase. Here's How Much You Could Pay in 2024
Source: ABC 7 News | By Dustin Dorsey
"Every increase that you hear about is just the tip of the iceberg,' The Utility Reform Network exec. director Mark Toney said. "And every increase that gets approved by the California Public Utilities Commission stacks on top of each other." The Utility Reform Network, or TURN, says the company wants to start collecting those increases from customers before the CPUC has even completed a proceeding with all parties involved.
Get ready to pay more on your electric bill. Last month, the California Public Utilities Commission approved a nearly 13% rate hike which you'll start seeing that on your bills starting Jan. 1. But now, PG&E has requested another hike and they're asking for another $2 billion.
PG&E Asks for Another Rate Hike Due to Climate Change
Source: KTVU | By Tom Vacar
Consumer group, The Utility Reform Network is hotly opposed. "It's gonna be between $12 and $20 additional each month. That's on top of the $33 that's coming January 1," said The Utility Reform Network’s Executive Director Mark Toney. Here's the kicker. "They want them to start collecting in March, even before the CPUC [California Public Utilities Commission] has held a proceeding and decided whether PG&E should get paid back by rate payers; two billion dollars for overspending," said Toney. One more kicker. "Oh, PG&E has several requests for at least another $3 billion," said Toney.
Climate change has aggravated inflation, but nowhere more than with Pacific Gas & Electric, the first major utility to deal with far more effects of extreme weather related to fire and floods. PG&E wants more money on top of the average $33 a month rate increase coming on New Year's Day.
PG&E Makes Another Request to Increase Rates
Source: The San Joaquin Valley Sun | By Reid Stone
The utility company is seeking an interim authorization to begin raising customers’ bills as early as March, even before the CPUC approves its latest rate increase proposal. Combined with the annual true up of energy costs that start in January, the rate increases could increase average monthly bills by $40 to $60, The Utility Reform Network (TURN) executive director Mark Toney told The Mercury News.
Pacific Gas and Electric is asking for another $1.46 billion from customers to cover costs for wildfire mitigation and catastrophic events. This comes less than one month after the utility’s request for rate increases was approved by the California Public Utilities Commission.